Why don’t reputable brokers offer futures trading

What are futures contracts in forex brokers? Futures trading in forex is among the financial derivatives that allow traders to predict the future value of a currency pair or an asset. Futures contracts have an expiration date. In this contract, the buyer or seller wants to trade at a defined price on a specific future date.

If a trader has determined that the price of a commodity will climb 10% from its present price, but he or she wants to earn more profit rather than purchasing shares of a certain stock, they will need leverage; hence, brokers give their clients a futures contract with an expiration date and leverage.

If they think a company's earnings release will cause its stock price to drop, they must short the stock to profit. Because futures are also two-sided, they require a future contract that allows them to sell something they do not own and buy it back at the appropriate time to profit. 

 

What is the legal status of futures trading?

 

Futures trading is legal in most countries as long as it is conducted on regulated exchanges and in compliance with local laws and regulations. Regulatory bodies like the CFTC, FCA, and others ensure that futures markets operate transparently and fairly, protecting both individual and institutional investors.

 

What are the main reasons to use Futures Trading?

 

Hedging: Many corporations might use futures contracts to hedge against potential risks and price fluctuations in commodities, currencies, or interest rates. For example, an airline may buy oil futures to protect against rising fuel costs.

Speculation: Some of the traders use futures contracts to speculate on the price rises and falls of commodities, stocks, or any kind of financial instrument, aiming to profit from market fluctuations.

Leverage: Futures trading provides users with leverage. Leverage is a tool that allows traders to control a large position with a relatively small amount of capital due to margin requirements. Such an approach will multiply potential profits but might as well increase risk.

Diversification: Some companies or businesses use futures to diversify their investment portfolios, aiming to reduce risk and balance their exposure to various assets. This helps manage risk and take advantage of growth opportunities in different markets.

Liquidity: One of the main reasons that big corporations and institutional fund managers or even hedge funds do most of their trading in futures markets is their high liquidity; it allows them to execute their trades rapidly and they can enter and exit their positions without significantly impacting the market price.

Managing Cash Flow: By locking in prices for future purchases or sales of goods, companies can better forecast their expenses and revenues. This helps stabilize cash flow and ensures that sudden price spikes or drops don’t disrupt their financial planning.

Access to better pricing: Companies with significant purchasing or selling needs can use futures markets to take advantage of favorable pricing. This allows them to plan their purchases or sales more strategically, often securing better prices than would be available in spot markets.

 

What's the difference between CFDs and futures?

 

In general, CFDs (contract for difference) function similarly to futures, providing the leverage that traders need. It allows users to trade both sides (long and short), but the most crucial feature is that CFDs have no time restriction.

In reality, CFDs exist because they replicate futures, but they are simpler and allow retail traders to place long or short positions without worrying about contract expiry or rollovers. 

On the contrary, futures trading is mostly used by institutional investors, hedge fund companies, and governmental entities. It actually was designed for these kinds of substantial capitals. They can afford to pay the high fees for the best liquidity, but a retail trader is best off using CFDs due to the lower fundamental and strategic risks.

 

What is the role of brokerage in futures contracts?

Brokers are indispensable in the futures markets, providing the necessary infrastructure, services, and support that enable traders to participate effectively. Their roles encompass

  1. Market Access and Execution: Facilitating entry into futures markets and executing trades efficiently.

  2. Clearing and Settlement: Managing the clearing process and ensuring proper settlement of trades.

  3. Risk Management and Leverage: Offering leverage, monitoring risk, and handling margin requirements.

  4. Providing Information and Research: Supplying real-time data, research, and educational resources.

  5. Compliance and Regulatory Adherence: Ensuring compliance with regulatory standards and promoting fair trading practices.

  6. Facilitating Order Types and Advanced Strategies: Supporting various order types and complex trading strategies.

  7. Providing Additional Services: Offering portfolio management, financial services, and tax/reporting assistance.

  8. Technology and Infrastructure Support: Maintaining robust, secure, and user-friendly trading platforms.

As is obvious, brokers’ role is not different from their usual services that they offer with CFDs, stocks, etc., so providing futures is not an advantage at all.

 

What are some of the drawbacks of futures contracts?

 

It is possible that the expiration date may seem intriguing; nevertheless, no one will ever know what will occur at a particular moment, which means that the risk will be far larger than it would be in normal trading. As an instance, the day of due for a future contract is scheduled for March 1st, and traders were anticipating the release of a certain economic report on February 28th. However, the report has been postponed for a week, and the price has not risen in their favor. They must realize their losses because they can't wait a week because the expiration date has already passed. This phenomenon resulted in the creation of a concept known as rollover, which enables traders to transfer their existing position on a particular future contract that is about to expire into another contract that has a longer expiration date. This gives them the opportunity to wait for the data that they have been anticipating, but the rollover process can be quite costly or even cause them to be subject to a margin call.

It can be difficult for retail users to add to their margin; even rollover fees can be rather expensive for them. Because of this, it is recommended that institutional traders use their futures and retail traders use CFDs for their trading, as this will result in less risk during their trades.

Many times, traders are required to manage their holdings on a short-term basis because of the daily settlement and margin calls that are associated with futures contracts. Due to the fact that regular traders may find this degree of intricacy and the possibility of losing more than their original investment to be intimidating, futures trading is not suited for many individuals.

In addition, brokers who provide futures must either be members of futures exchanges (such as CME, ICE, and others) or they must collaborate with clearing members who do business as intermediaries. As a result of the high cost of this membership, the operational expenses associated with providing futures contracts are increased.

For the purpose of managing margin needs, daily settlements, and position rollovers, futures trading necessitates the implementation of extensive back-office procedures. It takes a lot of resources to run these procedures.

There will be fees with all of these charges that will be collected from customers. It makes no sense that retail traders, who often have low margins and volumes, are required to pay such a high amount of commission and fees. Instead of bragging about something irrelevant that no one will use, it would be wise to give traders tools that are practical and logically appropriate for their needs. 

The CFDs, on the other hand, are more practical for retail users, as they simply allow traders to focus on their trades because there are no hidden fees or fundamental issues.

Summary

Futures trading absence in many reputable brokerage platforms is not an oversight but a deliberate strategic decision. It is rooted in fundamental differences in business models, regulatory frameworks, and the specific needs of their target audience. By specializing in contracts for difference (CFDs), these brokers create a more accessible and cost-effective ecosystem tailored for the retail trader. They avoid the significant operational complexities, exchange membership fees, and stringent margin requirements inherent in the futures market. Ultimately, this specialization allows them to offer key advantages like fractional trading, higher leverage, and a simpler user experience without fixed contract expiries. Therefore, a broker's credibility should not be judged by the absence of futures, but by the integrity of their offered services—be it forex or CFDs—backed by robust regulation, transparent pricing, and a steadfast commitment to client security. Their focus is simply on a different, yet equally valid, segment of the financial world.

Futures are two-sided, requiring contracts to sell without ownership and buy back later for profit.

Was this helpful?

0+