The type of brokers in forex is completely related to the trader. In the dynamic world of forex trading, choosing the right broker is critical to a trader’s success. Understanding the different types of forex brokers can help traders make informed decisions that align with their trading strategies and goals. This article explores the different types of forex brokers, providing insights into their operational models and how they influence trading experience.
How many types of forex brokers are there?
Based on their business models and trading mechanisms, we can categorize forex brokers into many types. Actually, the types of brokers in forex can be different and offer distinct features and benefits, catering to diverse trading needs.
However, there are 4 primary categories, each of which can be further subdivided into various subcategories. The primary types of forex brokers are:
-
NDD ( Non-Dealing Desk)
-
DD (Dealing Desk )
-
Market Makers
-
Hybrid
Understanding the nuances between these broker types can significantly impact a trader’s ability to execute trades efficiently and effectively.
For a comprehensive view, a detailed Fx broker review is often essential, as it provides an in-depth analysis of each broker’s strengths, weaknesses, and overall suitability for different trading styles.
NDD (No Dealing Desk) :
NDD or No Dealing Desk is a type of broker in financial markets, that allows traders to connect directly to Liquidity Providers, banking networks and other traders without any intervention from the trading desk.
NDD brokers often employ an execution model called ECN, STP, and DMA. These brokers offer direct market access. The primary distinction is that NDD brokers do not use a dealing desk to handle trades. Alternatively, they consolidate prices from multiple liquidity providers to offer the best available prices to their clients.
NDD brokers can offer raw and floating spreads, depending on the liquidity and market conditions. They mainly operate on a commission-based model, charging traders to obtain the optimal available prices. This approach ensures transparency and minimizes potential conflicts of interest, as NDD brokers do not trade against their clients.
-
ECN (Electronic Communication Network) Brokers
An ECN (Electronic Communication Network) is a type of trading system used in financial markets to facilitate direct trading between buyers and sellers, bypassing traditional market-making. ECN Electronic Communication Network is especially popular in forex trading but is also used in stock and other asset markets. Some keys for ECN Electronic Communication Network are as below:
Direct Market Access: ECNs provide direct access to the market, allowing traders to collaborate directly with other traders and liquidity providers. This can lead to tighter bid-ask spreads and clearer pricing.
Transparency: ECNs provide the best available bid and ask prices from multiple market participants, offering clear pricing and depth of market.
No Dealing Desk: ECNs run without a dealing desk, which means they do not act as intermediaries or create their own market.
ECN brokers operate differently from what most traders know about them. They offer a platform that links high-net-worth clients directly to the interbank forex market, enabling direct trading with other participants. However, it is vital to remember that retail users are unable to use this service; thus, many brokers that claim to offer ECN for retail users are simply using the term rather than the actual services.
ECN brokers do not take the opposite side of a trade, which eliminates the dispute of interest seen with LP. Alternatively, they earn money through a commission or a markup on the spread. The direct market access provided by ECN brokers allows for faster execution and more precise pricing, making them a preferred choice for high-frequency and professional traders.
-
STP Straight Through Processing Brokers:
STP brokers are recognized for their efficiency during order fulfillment. This type of broker processes orders directly through liquidity providers without passing them through a dealing desk. By routing orders straight to the market, STP brokers offer improved performance in speed and reduced slippage.
STP brokers typically provide variable spreads, which can widen during high volatility periods. They may charge a commission on trades, but their model reduces the potential for conflict of interest since they do not take the opposite side of a trade. Traders looking for rapid and transparent execution usually favor STP brokers.
STP Straight Through Processing brokers send your orders directly to the other party (LP). In addition to the spread, this type of broker also charges a commission for conducting transactions.
DD (Dealing Desk):
DD (Dealing Desk) brokers are ones that people must be aware of because there is no connection to the market and liquidity providers, also known as B-Book brokers. They play a counterparty role in their users’ trades. If users make a profit, they will lose money, and conversely, if their clients lose money, they will gain money, creating a conflict of interest. Therefore, these brokers are able to provide users with competitive and compelling offers, manipulating users into believing that their advantages outweigh their disadvantages. These brokers typically provide offers such as zero spreads, which are particularly appealing. Needless to say, STP or NDD brokers are able to offer this kind of situation, but they must bear the spread themselves because it exists in the real market and cannot be avoided unless they decide to pay it themselves as a marketing campaign, but its not cheap.
Market Maker Brokers:
Market Maker brokers are probably one of the most common types in the forex market. These brokers create their own market by setting bid and ask prices, just like DD brokers They often take the opposite side of a trader’s position, which means they may benefit when traders lose. Alternatively, they could establish a substantial liquidity pool within their platform, which is based on the number of users and AUM, eliminating the need for an external liquidity provider to transmit orders from the broker. Then they can offer fast order executions and the lowest latency, but they may have to charge higher spreads and slippages due to the difference between buyers and sellers. Once again, if they have such a huge liquidity pool, they can also offer competitive spreads and have minimum slippage.
One significant advantage of this kind of broker is their ability to offer fixed spreads, which can simplify trading costs while making it more expensive for traders. However, there is a potential conflict of interest since the broker might profit from a trader's losses. This model can lead to concerns about transparency and fairness, making it crucial for traders to conduct a thorough FX broker review before choosing this kind of broker.
Hybrid Brokers:
Additionally, this kind of broker, which combines elements from different types, has emerged as a popular choice among traders.
Hybrid brokers integrate components from different broker types to provide a blend of features. They may incorporate aspects of marketmaking, ECN, STP, and other NDD models to create a flexible trading environment. For example, a Hybrid Broker might offer both fixed and variable spreads, providing different options based on trading needs and market conditions.
The hybrid approach aims to offer the steadiness and predictability of fixed spreads from Market Makers, along with the transparency and direct market access of ECN and STP models. This versatility can be beneficial for traders with varying strategies and priorities.
